I don't consider it recycling at all, and we don't try and push any of it off as if it's new. I just mix in re-editted older stuff with the new scenes that we do, and the members love it. Keep in mind that our old stuff was all shorter scenes rendered at 320X240. I now do a "Director's Cut" and give them a much longer scene at a much higher quality. I bump the stuff up to 768X576 and at a high bitrate.
BTW, we offer 80+ sites for $19.95 a month
