Depends...
How big of a postcount does the alleged thief have?
How big of a postcount does the photog have?
Have I met either of them at a show for 5 minutes so I can attest to how honest they are?
Have either of them ever jumped into a thread to support me?
Have either of them ever jumped into a thread to attack me?
Which side are the "cool" posters on?
What sponsors are in their sigs?
Have either of them ever offered to lend me money?
Have either of them ever bought something from me?
Have either of them ever sent me TimTams?
Damn, there's more, but thats the crux of it. A question like this cannot be answered easily, lots of criteria to take into account.
