Remember Furry, just because they don't fit *your* beauty standards doesn't mean they won't fit someone else's. Hell, take a look at all the guys on GFY who think one pubic hair is too many and imagine how they'd react to your pics.
Better yet, look at Ron Jeremy... poor guy has let himself go so bad he should be doing Weight Watchers commercials, but he's *still* a highly sought-after stunt cock.
I say give the guy a chance at least. You never know, he might turn out to be great to work with and/or have a penis that would put Ron to shame. If nothing else, there are lots of webmasters over on LadyLynx.com who would die to have good photos of normal-looking men in softcore or solo action to go on their for-women sites. You can always shoot content of this guy and sell it rather than using it on your own site. Do one shoot, see how well it sells, and then make a decision about asking him back.